By Style
Butt Plugs
Butt plugs are designed to stay in place, with a tapered tip, a narrow neck and a flared base for safety. Start small and use plenty of lube.
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How We Make Money
465 Products
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Rechargeable Anal Beads Silicone Plug
Anal Fantasy
$70.00
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Collection Medium Silicone Plug
Anal Fantasy
$34.00
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Ass-Gasm Pro Vibrating Cockring & Plug
Anal Fantasy
$80.00
Blush Anal Adventures Matrix Teleportation Plug Lunar Blue
Blush
$46.00
Blush Anal Adventures Matrix Kinetik Plug with Remote Space Age Blue
Blush
$115.00
Blush Anal Adventures Matrix Bionic Plug with Remote Cosmic Copper
Blush
$115.00
Rocks Off Desire Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug with Remote Control
Rocks Off
$85.00
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Beginner's Anal Gaper Glass Tunnel Plug
Anal Fantasy
$50.00
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Elite Collection Auto-Throb Inflatable Vibrating Plug
Anal Fantasy
$135.00
Bathmate Anal Training Plugs 4-Piece Kit
Bathmate
$49.00
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Collection Vibrating Remote Control Silicone Plug
Anal Fantasy
$60.00
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Collection Silicone Insta-Gaper Expanding Plug
Anal Fantasy
$36.00
Pipedream Anal Fantasy Collection Inflatable Silicone Plug 4.25in
Anal Fantasy
$45.00
Simply Sweet Rainbow Silicone Butt Plug 3-Piece Set
Simply Sweet
$44.00
Simply Sweet Silicone Butt Plug Set
Simply Sweet
$39.00
Pipedream Fantasy For Her 3-Piece Silicone Her Little Gems Trainer Plug Set
Fantasy For Her
$40.00
Pipedream Fantasy For Her Silicone Her Little Gem Plug
Fantasy For Her
$25.00
Pipedream Icicles No. 91 Glass Anal Plug With Suction Cup
Icicles
$35.00
Pipedream Icicles No. 90 Glass Anal Plug With Suction Cup
Icicles
$31.00
Rear Assets Rose Gold Heart Plug - Small
Rear Assets
$20.00
Rear Assets Rose Gold Anal Plug - Medium
Rear Assets
$20.00
Playboy Spinning Tail Teaser Vibrating Rotating Anal Plug Salute
Playboy
$83.00
Playboy Pleasure 3 Ways 3-Piece Metal Anal Plug Set Hematite
Playboy
$69.00
ROMP Bass Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Anal Plug
ROMP
$30.00
Fifty Shades of Grey Sensation Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug
Fifty Shades
$40.00
We-Vibe Ditto+ App Compatible Vibrating Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug with Remote Control
We-Vibe
$129.00
TitanMen - Anal Stretcher - 6 Inch Expansion Plug
TitanMen
$29.00
TitanMen The Rumpy Smooth Cushioned Anal Plug
TitanMen
$29.00
Tailz Snap-On Small Silicone Anal Plug
Tailz
$17.00
Tailz Silicone Anal Plug & 3 Interchangeable Tails
Tailz
$36.00
Tailz Rainbow Unicorn Tail Anal Plug
Tailz
$29.00
Tailz Vibrating White Fox Tail Slender Anal Plug
Tailz
$50.00
Tailz Rainbow Pony Tail Anal Plug
Tailz
$31.00
Tailz White Fluffy Bunny Tail Anal Plug
Tailz
$23.00
Tailz Rainbow Tail Silicone Butt Plug
Tailz
$50.00
Tailz Blondie's Pony Tail Butt Plug
Tailz
$29.00
Tailz Midnight Fox Glass Butt Plug with Tail
Tailz
$29.00
Tailz Bunny Tail Anal Plug
Tailz
$21.00
Tailz Fox Tail Glass Anal Plug
Tailz
$35.00
Tailz Fox Tail Anal Plug
Tailz
$38.00
STRICT Male Harness with Silicone Anal Plug
STRICT
$49.00
Prisms Erotic Glass Dosha 3 Piece Glass Plug Kit
Prisms Erotic Glass
$39.00
Prisms Erotic Glass Asvini Glass Penis Anal Plug
Prisms Erotic Glass
$35.00
Heavy Hitters Comfort Plugs Premium Silicone
Heavy Hitters
$20.00
Heavy Hitters Premium Silicone Weighted Anal Plug
Heavy Hitters
$25.00
Vac-U-Lock - Large Black Suction Cup Plug
Vac U Lock
$25.00
Red Boy - Butt Plug - Red Ringer Anal Wand
Red Boy
$20.00
Red Boy - Butt Plug
Red Boy
$25.00