By Style
Butt Plugs
Butt plugs are designed to stay in place, with a tapered tip, a narrow neck and a flared base for safety. Start small and use plenty of lube.
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. How We Make Money
465 Products
Crystal Delights Minx Faux Fur Tail Plug
Crystal Delights
$80.00
Crystal Delights Minx Pony Tail Plug – Rainbow
Crystal Delights
$80.00
Ouch! International Venice Collection Metal Anal Plug Set
Ouch!
$39.00
Ouch! International Paris Collection Metal Anal Plug Set
Ouch!
$39.00
Ouch! International Paris Collection Metal Anal Plug Set
Ouch!
$39.00
Ouch! International New York Collection Metal Anal Plug Set
Ouch!
$48.00
Ouch! International Milan Collection Metal Anal Plug Set
Ouch!
$48.00
Heavy Hitters Vibrating Weighted Silicone Anal Plug
Heavy Hitters
$66.00
Mystim Bold Boris Dildo Ball Plug
Mystim
$98.00
Oh My Gem Prestige Glass Anal Plug
Oh My Gem
$40.00
Oh My Gem Lustre Glass Anal Plug
Oh My Gem
$38.00
Creature Cocks Unicorn Swirl Silicone Butt Plug
Creature Cocks
$26.00
Creature Cocks Eye of the Spawn Rechargeable Silicone Vibrating & Squirming Butt Plug
Creature Cocks
$68.00
CalExotics Silicone Anal Exerciser Anal Plug Set (3 Per Set)
CalExotics
$35.00
CalExotics Naughty Bits Shake Your Ass Petite Vibrating Silicone Rechargeable Butt Plug
CalExotics
$54.00
CalExotics Boundless Vibrating X5 Beaded Plug Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug
CalExotics
$30.00
CalExotics Boundless Vibrating Beaded Plug Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug
CalExotics
$30.00
CalExotics Boundless Vibrating Slim Plug Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug
CalExotics
$30.00
B-Vibe Butties Slide Silicone Butt Plug
B-Vibe
$29.00
B-Vibe Butties Pop Beaded Silicone Anal Plug
B-Vibe
$29.00
B Vibe Butties Dart Silicone Anal Plug
B-Vibe
$29.00
Alien Nation Sprite Silicone Anal Plug
Alien Nation
$39.00
Atomic Thrusting Light-Up Rechargeable Silicone Power Plug with Remote Control
Atomic
$49.00
Atomic Thrusting Light-Up Twister Rechargeable Silicone Plug with Remote Control
Atomic
$49.00
Anal-Ese Collection Rechargeable Vibrating Silicone Alpha Plug #3
Anal-Ese
$44.00
Anal-Ese Collection Rechargeable Vibrating Silicone Alpha Plug #2
Anal-Ese
$44.00
Techno Prism Rechargeable Silicone App Compatible Anal Plug
Techno
$54.00
Techno Trance Rechargeable Silicone App Compatible Anal Plug
Techno
$46.00
CalExotics Expandable Silicone Inflatable Plug
CalExotics
$38.00
Creature Cocks Red Eye Metal Butt Plug
Creature Cocks
$18.00
Eye of the Dragon Silicone Butt Plug
Creature Cocks
$29.00
Oh My Gem Charm Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug
Oh My Gem
$50.00
Noah App Controlled Rechargeable Silicone Rotating Butt Plug
Honey Play Box
$79.00
Renegade Orion Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Plug
Renegade
$44.00
Renegade Maverick Rechargeable Vibrating Anal Plug
NS Novelties
$44.00
B-Vibe Jewel Metal Anal Plug Training Set (2 Piece)
B-Vibe
$39.00
B Vibe Pink Roses Glass Butt Plug Training Set 2Pc
B-Vibe
$49.00
Unicorn Swirl Silicone Butt Plug
Creature Cocks
$29.00
Luxe Little Thumper Silicone Vibrating Butt Plug
Luxe
$34.00
Luxe Discover Silicone Vibrator Butt Plug
Luxe
$32.00
Anal Adventures Matrix Swirling Bling Silicone Plug
Anal Adventures
$26.00
Anal Adventures Matrix Wavy Bling Silicone Plug
Anal Adventures
$26.00
Ouch! Smooth Silicone Oval Anal Plug 4.6 in.
Ouch!
$26.00
Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Vibrating Plug
Blush
$28.00
Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone 3-Piece Beginner Plug Kit
Blush
$28.00
Blush Anal Adventures Basic Butt Plug Kit – Perfect for Beginners & Exploration
Blush
$32.00
Creature Cocks Dragonspawn Silicone Butt Plug
Creature Cocks
$29.00
Love to Love Twinny Bud Rechargeable Silicone Multi-Speed Vibrating Anal Plug
Love to Love
$40.00